Scott Michael Foster Talks Once Upon a Time, Frozen, and Where the Cast of Greek Is Now

So, changing gears, I have to talk about Greek. I was a huge fan. Where's Cappie now?

Well, I would like to think that he's still with Casey in Washington, D.C., and living happily ever after. I did a TV show that didn't last on ABC called The Zero Hour, and my character was working at a magazine. When that came out, people online were like, "Oh, Cappie's in New York working at a magazine now!" I was like, "Completely different show." I would like to think that instead of that he's still with Casey in their red Prius driving around—never stopping anywhere, just driving forever off into a sunset.

Does the cast still keep in touch?

Yeah! Actually, the reason I'm out here [in NYC] for this trip is because Jake McDorman, who played Evan, is doing a show for ABC, Manhattan Love Story. We're really close. I hang out with Paul James, who played Calvin, and Jacob Zachar, who played Rusty. Amber Stevens (Ashleigh) is getting married to Andy West, who played the character Fisher—he was the hot guy that worked at the Zeta Beta House. They've been together for, like, six years.

What?! They're getting married? My mind is blown.

I know, I know. The only people I don't see a lot is Clark Duke [who played Dale]. He's busy. And I never see Spencer Grammer (Casey). She's got a baby, so she's being mom of the year.

I feel like the show was ahead of its time. Like, if it came on when Netflix and Hulu were around, it would have been around longer.

Absolutely. I think, honestly, the reason it's still talked about and revered today is because of Netflix. The entire show is on Netflix, and I think more people have watched it since it's been on Netflix than people who watched it when it was on TV. It's gotten sort of a cult following, which is really cool. Nobody expected that to happen when we were shooting it. I think if any of these platforms were doing what they're doing now in 2010 or 2011, we might have gone on further. Who knows.

Once Upon a Time premieres Sunday, September 28, at 8 P.M./7 P.M CT.